Executive Team Development for New Leaders: Read the Team Before You Change It
A new leader’s mandate for results can create pressure to reshape the inherited team quickly. Early changes to roles or reporting lines can signal decisiveness but may also fix the wrong problem.
Executive team development starts with an assessment of the current team. The first weeks are the best window, before the leader’s own changes obscure how the team worked before the transition.
Key Takeaways
- Assess before you restructure — The Transition Roadmap puts the team assessment ahead of any reshaping, so changes rest on what the leader learned in the first weeks.
- Separate structure from people — A team problem can come from unclear roles, decision rights, or workload. Replacing a person won’t address any of these.
- Look past the org chart — A team’s formal structure won’t tell a new leader who handles most of the work or how the team deals with disagreement but one-on-ones and team meetings will.
- Protect an early source of support — In a Genesis and Egon Zehnder survey, new leaders were more likely to say their teams supported them to a very great extent than any other group.
- Start team support early — Executive team coaching works best in a leader’s first months, though a team can benefit at any stage.
Why Executive Team Development Starts With Assessing the Team
The Transition Roadmap, built on the framework from “The First 90 Days” by Genesis co-founder Michael Watkins, sets out three steps for building a team:
- Identify the roles and skills the team needs.
- Assess each member’s strengths and development areas.
- Reshape and align the team.
The order matters because the team is often one of a new leader’s strongest allies. Genesis and Egon Zehnder asked newly hired leaders how much support they received from key stakeholders, and Watkins reports the results in “How to Effectively Onboard and Integrate Your Executive Talent.”
Stakeholder group | Supported the new leader to a very great extent |
Team | 30% |
Line manager | 25% |
HR partner | 16% |
A restructuring that comes before the leader understands the team puts that support at risk.
Structure Problem or People Problem?
An issue a new leader spots in the first weeks can come from one of two sources:
- Structural problems come from how the team is set up: who owns which decisions, how work is divided, and how the team communicates.
- People problems come from an individual’s skills, fit, or willingness to adapt.
Each type calls for a different response. Moving or replacing a person won’t resolve a structural problem. A new org chart won’t resolve a performance problem. Each area below ends with a check to run before making a change.
Look Past the Org Chart to See Who Carries the Work
An org chart lays out who reports to whom, but not who colleagues go to for answers, who covers for gaps, or whose departure would stall a project. Early one-on-ones and a few weeks of watching how work moves through the team give a more accurate picture.
A heavy load on one person can point in either direction. That person may be the team’s strongest performer or role structure may be pushing work toward whoever is willing to take it.
Before you change it: Ask whether the workload follows from how roles are defined. If so, redefine the roles before making decisions about the people in them.
Watch How the Team Handles Disagreement and Difficult News
Trust problems are harder to see from the leader’s seat. A team may stay polite in meetings and hold the real discussion afterward, or defer every difficult call to the leader. Useful signs include whether people raise problems early, whether disagreement happens in the room, and whether team members share information with one another or only with the leader.
Thin trust can have a structural cause. A previous leader who made decisions alone can leave a team without the habit of open debate, even when the relationships between members are sound.
Before you change it: Find out whether the trust problem sits between specific people or runs across the team. A pattern across the whole team usually points to how it has been run.
How does your team compare? Take the quiz How High-Performing Is Your Team? to see where your team stands across five areas of team performance.
Assess the Role Before You Assess the Person
A team member who appears to underperform may hold a role with unclear scope, competing priorities, or decision rights that sit with someone else. Before judging the person, a new leader should ask whether anyone could succeed in the role as it’s set up.
The leader’s strategy matters here too. A role designed for the previous direction may not fit the new one. In that case the role needs redesigning first, and the person in it may still be a strong fit.
Before you change it: Write down what the role needs to deliver under the new strategy. Then assess the person against that description.
Case Study: Building One Team Across a Healthcare System’s Acquired Units
A Genesis case study from a major healthcare system shows how this assessment works when a leader inherits units that have never operated as one team.
The situation: A physician leader and researcher was recruited to lead the system’s cancer service line. The system had grown through acquisitions. His task was to unite units with different cultures, strategies, and operating systems into one national service line.
What the coaching covered: His executive coach worked with him using the Transition Roadmap, with four focus areas:
- Assessing and building his team
- Defining key leadership roles
- Establishing direction for the service line
- Gaining alignment with the CEO and other executives
The result: A year into the role, he had rallied the team around a common strategy and way of working. An anonymous feedback survey at the one-year mark rated his vision, inclusiveness, and leadership highly.
When Executive Team Coaching Makes Sense
A new leader can do much of this assessment alone. Outside support helps when the team is large or senior, when it has significant problems, or when the leader needs candid input from team members early on. Executive team coaching gives the team a structured way to assess itself and agree on how it will work together.
Genesis offers two types of support for leaders building a team in a new role:
- Team Development Accelerator: Team coaching services that begin with an assessment of the team, then focus on the areas where it needs the most development.
- Acceleration Coaching: One-on-one transition coaching for the leader, including support for gaining alignment with an inherited team.
Team support works best in a leader’s first months, while the team is still forming its view of the new leader. A team further along can still benefit, especially after a change in strategy or membership.
FAQ
What is executive team development?
Executive team development is the work of building a senior team’s ability to deliver results together. It covers how the team aligns on goals, divides roles and decisions, communicates, and builds trust. For a new leader, it starts with an assessment of the team they inherited.
How long should a new leader wait before changing the team?
There’s no fixed timeline. The Transition Roadmap places the team assessment before any reshaping, so changes should follow a clear assessment of each member and the roles the new strategy requires. Urgent problems may call for faster action.
How is executive team coaching different from individual coaching?
Individual coaching works with one leader on their own goals and transition. Executive team coaching works with the team as a group on shared goals, ways of working, and collaboration. A new leader can benefit from both at once.
How do you assess an inherited executive team?
Start with the roles and skills the team needs under the new strategy. Then use one-on-ones, team meetings, and the work itself to see who carries the load, where trust is thin, and whether problems trace back to structure or to individuals.
When do team coaching services make sense?
Team coaching services help when a team is large, senior, or facing significant change, or when the leader needs a structured way to gather candid input. Starting in a leader’s first months gives the most benefit, though teams can gain from support at any stage.
See Where Your Team Stands
Take the quiz How High-Performing Is Your Team? to get a clearer picture of the team you inherited and where to focus first.
To talk through which type of support fits your situation, book a call with Genesis.
Read More
Genesis is a global provider of leadership development programs, coaching, and transition acceleration solutions for individuals, teams, and organizations. Genesis offerings are based on the research of Michael Watkins, co-founder and author of the book "The First 90 Days." Genesis provides a comprehensive range of programs, coaching processes, and consulting services aimed at speeding up transitions at all levels, from front-line managers to C-level executives.


